Auditor General report on Kanyuambora haunts former principal Moshee Musyoka as claims of KCSE irregularities resurfaces as KNEC puts Nyangwa Boys in their radar


The Principal of Kanyuambora Boys High School may soon be summoned before the Parliamentary Committee on Public Investment and Education to address audit inquiries raised by the Auditor General regarding the institution's financial management during the 2024 fiscal year, when he served as principal.

In an interview with the Nairobi Daily News, the current principal of Kanyuambora Boys stated that the audit report documents instances of mismanagement that occurred during his predecessor's tenure and emphasized that he assumed leadership of the institution in 2026, making him relatively new to the position. He disclosed that he has inherited an institution burdened with substantial outstanding liabilities, inadequate infrastructure, and strained relationships between the school administration and both the Board of Governors and the Parents Association—organizational divisions created by his predecessor, who demonstrated disrespect toward the board. Regarding academic performance, the current principal indicated that he has assumed control of a school experiencing stagnation and declining educational outcomes. He reported that the institution's mean examination score has deteriorated progressively during his predecessor's administration. The mean score was 4.0 in 2022, declined to 3.0 in 2023, returned to 4.0 in 2024, and improved to 6.0 in 2025. The current principal has also attributed disciplinary challenges to his predecessor, having received reports from students regarding cases of same-sex relationships within the school involving the sexual exploitation of younger students by older peers. 

He confirmed that his predecessor failed to address these reported incidents, and students believed he either covertly supported the prohibited activities associated with the LGBTQ movement or was himself a member of this organization. Additionally, allegations have emerged that his predecessor engaged in an extramarital relationship with a married member of the teaching staff, an action that faculty members contended damaged the school's institutional image and reputation. It has further been established that during the most recent KCSE examination period, his predecessor facilitated examination irregularities among candidates to artificially inflate the mean score, as parents and stakeholders were demanding accountability for the institution's poor academic performance.

The performance metrics demonstrated an improvement to 6.1 in 2025, attributed to the irregularities facilitated by Musyoka, with sixteen students successfully achieving the university admission threshold. Musyoka has subsequently placed both Kanyuambora and his present institution, Nyangwa, under scrutiny by the Kenya National Examination Council (KNEC) regarding potential involvement in the 2026 KCSE examination. Several stakeholders have already submitted formal correspondence to KNEC requesting an investigation into Musyoka's conduct at Nyangwa during the examination period.


School Board of Management - Board Members
The School Board of Management, established pursuant to Section 55 of the Basic Education Act, 2013, comprises the following members: 1 Pius Nthiga Chairman 25/04/2022 2 Moshe M. Musyoka Secretary - Principal 25/04/2022 3 Francis Mbaka Member 25/04/2022 4 Nicasio Nyaga Member 25/04/2022 5 Lilian Muthoni Member 25/04/2022 6 Michael Makunyi Member 25/04/2022 7 Mercy Karendi Member 25/04/2022 8 Justus K. Mate Member - Representative, County Education Board 25/04/2022 9 Peter Nderitu Member, Representative, Teachers 25/04/2022 10 Rev. William Nyaga, Patrick Njeru, Eunice Mukami Three Members - Sponsor Representatives 25/04/2022 11 Chief Njeru Kithenge, Hampton Ireri Member - Community Representative 25/04/2022 12 Victor Nyaga Member, Special Needs Representative 25/04/2022
13 Kena Lita Representative, Student Body 25/04/2022 

REPORT OF THE AUDITOR.GENERAL ON KANYUAMBORA BOYS HIGH SCHOOL FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE, 2025- EMBU COUNTY

Unsupported Payments 

The statement of financial performance reflects infrastructure and boarding and school fund expenditure totalling Kshs.39,328,340 as disclosed in Notes 8 and 9 to the financial statements. However, examination of the payment vouchers amounting to Kshs.13,599,344 revealed that Management made payments without proper supporting documents such as requisitions, local purchase orders, written contracts between the School and contractors and suppliers, inspection and acceptance committee reports, goods received notes, interim certificates and progress reports. ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of expenditure for infrastructure and boarding and schoolfund of Kshs.39,328,340 could not be confirmed.

Unrecoverable Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables 

I draw attention to Note 13 to the financial statements regarding accounts receivables in respect of fees arrears amounting to Kshs.11,270,317 which had been outstanding for over three (3) years. The amount includes Kshs.10,262,521 in respect to students who have since left the School after completion of their studies. This casts doubt on full recoverability of the account's receivables balance. Further, Management has not developed a policy on the impairment of long outstanding fees arrears. The continued existence of these receivables exposes the School to the risk of possible financial loss.

Over and Under Funding of Capitation Grants 

The statement of financial performance reflects Government grants for tuition and operations amount of Kshs.1 ,787 ,701 and Kshs.7,522,947 , respectively as disclosed in Notes 1 and 2 to the financial statements. During the financial year, the School was overfunded and underfunded by Kshs.430,986 and Kshs.1,7T1,os2 respectively as a result of variances in student's enrolment records between the National Education Management and lnformation System (NEMIS) and enrolment records provided by the School.


 Lack of Approved Budget 

The statement of budgeted versus actual amounts reflects final budget of Kshs.54,223,200. However, during the period under review, the School did not have an approved budget by the Board of Management. This was contrary to Section 68(2)(h) of the Public Finance Managemenl Act,2012, and Paragraph 16(1) and (2) of the Fourth Schedule of the Basic Education Act, 2013 which require that the Accounting Officer and Board of Management of a basic education institution prepare annual estimates of revenue and expenditure for the institution under their charge and ensure it is approved by the Cabinet Secretary responsible for matters relating to basic education and training. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.


Non-Compliance with the Law on Procurement 

The statement of financial performance reflects total payments of Kshs.51 ,574,O74which includes an amount of Kshs.19,602,159 in respect to procurements undertaken by the School. However, although the School prepared a Procurement Plan during the year, the plan was not approved by the Board of Management. This was contrary to Section 45(3) and Section 53(2) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 which requires that the accounting officer prepare an Annual Procurement Plan as part of the annual budget preparations process and Regulation 40 (4) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020 which requires that procuring entity shall not commence any procurement proceedings unless the procurement is included in the approved procurement plan. 

Further, the School did not have an established procurement function managed by qualified procurement professional as required under Section 47(1) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 and Regulation 33 of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020. The School did not also seek to transfer the procurement function through other alternative procurement structures as guided by Sections 51 and 52 of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015.

ln addition, the Management did not appoint tender opening and evaluation committees for the procurements reviewed contrary to the provisions of Sections 46 (1) and 78 (1) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. Further, there was no evidences of professional opinion and notification of award sent to successful and unsuccessful bidders. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.


Construction of a School Library and Laboratory 

The statement of financial performance reflects payments of Kshs.5,975,030 in respect of infrastructure as disclosed in Note 8 to the financial statements. lncluded in the payments is an amount of Kshs.4,563,330 paid for the construction of a School library and laboratory. 

The School was given approval by the State Department for Basic Education to use the repair and maintenance grant towards the construction of a library at a cost of Kshs.2,778,496. The School received an infrastructure grant of Kshs.2,000,000 in the 202312024 financial year from the State Department for Basic Education and the School engaged contractors in a labour-based contract towards the projects. However, review of procurement documents revealed that the constructions were ongoing but the contractors were not competitively sourced. 

This was contrary to Section 91 of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. ln the circumstances, the Management was in breach of the law. 


Excess Supply of Books 

During the year under review, the Ministry of Education did not distribute any textbooks to the School. However, review of textbooks data distributed to the School in previous years revealed that the School received 12,368 books while 3,806 books were issued to the students resulting in an unexplained excess textbook of 8,562 in the School store. There was no value for money on the excess 8,562 text books to the School. 


Non-Deduction of Capacity Building Levy 

The statement of financial performance reflects payments amount of Kshs.51 ,574,074 as disclosed in the financial statements which includes an amount of Kshs.19,602,159 in respect of procurement contracts signed with the School's suppliers. Review of payments for goods and services revealed that there was no deduction of the public procurement capacity building levy of 0.03% on the contracts amounting to Kshs.5,880. This was contrary to the Levy Order, 2023 issued by the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority. ln the circumstances, the Management was in breach of the law.


Irregular Transfer of Funds to School Heads Associations 

The statement of financial performance reflects operations and boarding and school fund expenditure of Kshs.42,538,399 as disclosed in Notes 7 and 9 to the financial statements. lncluded in the expenditure is an amount of Kshs.751,600 transferred to Kenya Secondary Schools Heads Association (KESSHA) and Kshs.180,000 transferred to Association of Principals of ACK Sponsored Schools (APACKSS).

However, KESSHA and APACKSS are welfare organizations that draw their membership from School Principals only. The organizations are not defined in Government Funding system and there is no assurance that they have implemented effective, efficient, and transparent financial management and internal control systems to manage the funds transferred by schools. 

ln the circumstances, the legality and value for money for funds transferred to KESSHA and APACKSS amounting to Kshs.931,600 could not be confirmed. 


Weakness in Board of Management 

Review of the Board of Management (BoM) minutes dated 09 May,2022 revealed that the School BoM for the period 2022 to 2025 was constituted. However, the appointment letters for each BoM Member were not provided for audit review. ln addition, its Committees did not convene any meetings. The absence of Committee meetings may have limited the Board's ability to provide effective supervision, assess operational performance, and ensure accountability in decision-making processes. 

ln the circumstances, this may expose the entity to risks associated with weak internal controls, delayed decision-making, and inadequate oversight. 


Lack of Strategic Plan 

Review of the School operations revealed that the School did not have a Strategic Plan since 2018. The School lacks a toolthat provides a clear strategic direction and efficiently allocate resources towards the achievement of certain goals in line with the vision and mission of the entity. ln the circumstances, the School may not effectively manage and align its activities with its long-term objectives.


Lack of a Risk Management Policy 

During the year under review, the School had not established a risk management policy. Therefore, Management is not able to identify, assess, monitor and control risks that may minimize the School's ability to reach the set objectives as required by Regulation 165 (1) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015. ln the circumstances, Management may fail to identify potential risks and the corresponding mitigating measures to be taken during the unfortunate events. 




Post a Comment

0 Comments