The recently released Auditor General's report for Gatue Mixed Secondary School in Tharaka Nithi County has unveiled significant issues regarding mismanagement and corruption under the leadership of Minnie Wangari Muturi. The report, covering the fiscal year ending on June 30, 2025, has raised concerns among stakeholders and highlighted the urgent need for reforms.
Financial Mismanagement
Pending Bills and Supplier Payments
A significant issue highlighted is the accumulation of high pending bills. The report suggests that Ms. Muturi has favored suppliers who offer her kickbacks, resulting in many creditors not being paid in a timely manner. This practice has not only strained the school's financial resources but also damaged its reputation among local suppliers.
Declining Academic Standards
The school’s academic performance has suffered under Ms. Muturi's leadership. The dwindling mean scores reflect a lack of focus on educational excellence, which stakeholders attribute to the principal's absenteeism and ineffective management. The deputy principal, Mr. Njeru, and the school accountant have been left to manage day-to-day operations, further complicating the situation.
Allegations of Immorality and Misconduct
The report also brings to light allegations of personal misconduct. Members of the Parents Association and the Board of Management express concerns over Ms. Muturi's alleged involvement in an illicit affair with a board member. Additionally, it is suspected that she has used inappropriate means, including offering personal favors, to influence sub-county auditors.
Calls for Reform
The findings from the Auditor General's report have sparked calls for immediate action and reform. Parents, board members, and teachers are urging for a thorough investigation into the allegations and for appropriate measures to be taken to restore integrity and accountability at Gatue Mixed Secondary School.
In conclusion, the report underscores the urgent need for leadership change and the implementation of stringent measures to address the issues of corruption and mismanagement. It is imperative that the educational and ethical standards of the school be restored to ensure a conducive learning environment for students.
REPORT OF THE AUDITOR.GENERAL ON GATUE MIXED DAY SECONDARY SCHOOL FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE,2025
1. Late Submission of Financial Statements for Audit
During the year under review, Management submitted the financial statements to the Auditor-General on 4 March, 2026, instead of the statutory deadline of 31 August, 2025. This was contrary to The National Treasury Circular No. AG.3/88 VOL.VII (41) of 4th December, 2024, which aligns with Section 81 of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. In these circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.
2. Non-Compliance with Public Sector Accounting Standards Board Reporting Requirements
The financial statements presented for audit did not include all information as prescribed by the Public Sector Accounting Standards Board (PSASB):
The summary report of performance had inaccurate opening balances on capitation from the ministry, the ratio of capitation, and three-year growth of expenditure.
Note 19 Stock/Inventory and biological assets under Note 17 were not disclosed.
The financial statements approval date was not indicated.
Consequently, Management did not comply with PSASB guidelines, which may affect users' reliance on the financial statements for decision making.
3. Irregular Transfer of Funds to Kenya Secondary Schools Heads Association
The statement of financial performance reflects payment for operations amounting to Kshs.1,326,420, as disclosed in Note 7. Included is Kshs.421,605 transferred to the Kenya Secondary School Heads Association (KESSHA), a welfare organization not defined in the Government Funding system. There is no assurance that KESSHA has effective financial management and internal control systems to manage the funds. Thus, the value for money transferred to KESSHA could not be confirmed.
4. Overfunding of Capitation Grants and Inaccuracy of Student Enrollment Data
The statement of financial performance reflects capitation grants totaling Kshs.1,173,378. During the financial year, NEMIS reported 69 students, while the enrolment records indicated 55 students, resulting in an unexplained variance of 14 students. This led to an overfunding of Kshs.355,889.66, potentially affecting service delivery to other public schools.
5. Excess Supply of Books
The Kenya Institute of Curriculum Development (KICD) distributed 1,145 books to the school, while only 725 were issued to students, leaving an excess of 420 books. Additionally, some books from the previous year were still unused. Consequently, the value for money on the excess textbooks could not be confirmed.
6. Failure to Deduct and Remit Housing Levy for Temporary Staff
Included in the operations payments of Kshs.1,326,420 are personnel emoluments costs of Kshs.521,804. The School failed to deduct and remit housing levy deductions from temporary workers, contrary to the Affordable Housing Act CAP. 117A. Therefore, Management was in breach of the law.
7. Non-Compliance with Law on Budget Preparation
The School Management did not prepare budget estimates for revenue and non-revenue transactions, contrary to Regulations 31 (1) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015. Thus, Management was in breach of the law.
8. Lack of an Approved School Improvement Plan
The School did not have an approved School Improvement Plan, contrary to Section 2.2 of the Ministry of Education Operation Manual. The school was underfunded relative to its operational and infrastructure needs, with no infrastructure grant received in five years. This lack of funding has resulted in stalled infrastructure projects and deteriorating facilities.
9. Irregularities in Procurement Processes
9.1 Lack of Inspection and Acceptance Committee Reports
There was no inspection and acceptance report for goods and services paid during the financial year due to the absence of an appointed inspection and acceptance committee as required by PPADA, 2015.
9.2 Lack of a Functional Procurement Unit
The school lacked an established procurement function managed by qualified professionals, contrary to the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015.
9.3 Lack of a Procurement Plan
Management did not prepare an annual procurement plan, contrary to Regulation 40 of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020.
10. Non-Deduction of Capacity Building Levy
The school procured goods and services primarily on a cash-and-carry basis without formal contracts, leading to non-deduction of the capacity building levy as required by the Public Procurement Regulations and Disposal Act Circular.
In these circumstances, Management was in breach of the law in several areas, which may have affected the school’s operational efficiency and financial accountability.
Report on Effectiveness of Internal Controls, Risk Management, and Governance
1. Non-Maintenance of Buildings
The examination of records revealed that the school maintains five classrooms, one laboratory, and a kitchen. However, a physical inspection conducted in March 2026 showed deteriorating conditions, including leaky roofs and unfinished laboratory and kitchen constructions. The absence of a defined fence makes the school vulnerable to trespassers, negatively affecting the learning environment.
2. Absence of Electricity Connection
The school operates without electricity, being disconnected from the national power grid and not exploring alternative sources like solar energy. This lack results in challenges such as the inability to use computers and ICT equipment, no access to digital learning platforms, difficulty in conducting science practicals, and inadequate security lighting.
3. Failure to Prepare Annual Reports on Governance
The Board of Management failed to submit annual governance reports as mandated by Section 60 of the Basic Education Act, 2013. This omission suggests that the Board may not have effectively executed its responsibilities.
4. Lack of Audit Committee
The school did not establish an audit committee as required by Section 73 (5) of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. This absence raises concerns about the effectiveness of internal controls.
5. Weaknesses in the Board of Management
The Board of Management is appointed by the County Director of Education, but essential documents such as gazette notices, meeting minutes, and attendance registers were not provided. This lack of documentation indicates potential mishandling of the Board's mandate.
6. Poor Evaluation of Board of Management Employees
The financial performance statement includes Kshs.1,326,420 for personnel emoluments, but there is a lack of contracts, muster rolls, and appraisals for the staff. This deficiency questions the efficiency and effectiveness of both teaching and non-teaching staff.
7. Lack of Risk Management Policy
The school lacks an approved Risk Management Policy and a Risk Register, which impedes the documentation and mitigation of risks. This shortfall affects the implementation of effective risk management strategies.
8. Poor Inventory Management
No stocktake was conducted, and there was no proper inventory management system in place. This oversight violates Section 162(1) of the Public Assets Disposal Act, 2015, and results in ineffective control over school stocks.
9. Unconfirmed Land Ownership and Asset Register
The school claims ownership of 40 acres of land, but a pending legal dispute prevents the processing of the title. Additionally, the school lacks an updated fixed assets register, leaving asset management measures unconfirmed.
10. Lack of Segregation of Duties
There is no segregation of duties in revenue collection and procurement, violating Regulation 64. (1 (a)) of the Public Finance Management Regulations, 2015. This breach raises concerns about the effectiveness of internal controls.
11. Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables
The accounts receivables balance includes Kshs.2,212,704 outstanding for over two years, with no recoveries made. The absence of a policy on impairment of long outstanding arrears casts doubt on the recoverability of these balances.
In conclusion, the identified issues indicate significant areas for improvement in internal controls, risk management, and governance. Addressing these concerns is crucial for ensuring effective and lawful school operations.

0 Comments