Employees at Delfy Security Limited are expressing their discontent towards the management, whom they accuse of authoritarian behavior, intimidation, coercion, failure to pay overtime, a toxic work environment, and unjust termination of employment.
According to several employees who spoke to us on the condition of anonymity due to fears of retaliation, the management has been mistreating security personnel, offering inadequate pay, failing to provide housing allowances, and neglecting overtime compensation. Those who have the courage to assert their rights face dismissal without any compensation. Additionally, it has been reported that some senior managers engage in sexual harassment of female employees, soliciting sexual favors in exchange for promotions. Employees who resist these inappropriate advances are often transferred, victimized, or terminated without compensation. The upper management asserts that they have a close relationship with COTU Secretary General Francis Atwoli, claiming they pay him protection fees monthly, which they believe shields them from any labor official's scrutiny. Our attempts to contact Atwoli for verification were unsuccessful as he did not respond to our calls. A notable instance of unjust termination without compensation involves the appellant, Isaac Murunga.
Judgment Appeal E010 of 2026
Introduction
This document pertains to the appeal case between Delfy Security Limited, the appellant, and Isaac Murunga, the respondent, being an appeal from the judgment of the Magistrates' Court at Mombasa (Honourable Lucy Khahendi Sindani) dated the 18th of December, 2025. The appeal is presided over by Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson.
Grounds of Appeal
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 15th January, 2026, Delfy Security Limited appeals against the entire judgment on several grounds, including:
The trial magistrate erred in holding that the termination was unfair both procedurally and substantially.
The magistrate was incorrect in the finding that the termination was unfair despite evidence that the respondent had deserted employment for another company.
The magistrate erred in holding that the appellant did not follow up on the alleged desertion.
A failure to evaluate the documentary evidence presented, with the respondent not providing pay slips or adhering to minimum wage regulations.
The magistrate erred in awarding house allowance and underpayment claims without sufficient documentary evidence.
The magistrate erred in awarding the claim for overtime without adequate evidence.
Appellant’s Submissions
The appellant, through their counsel, argued:
The trial court wrongly awarded underpayment, overtime, and house allowance without sufficient evidence.
The burden of proof for underpayment lies with the respondent, who failed to provide necessary wage orders or legal notices.
The respondent did not adequately substantiate claims for overtime.
The house allowance claim was subject to a statutory limitation period of twelve months, which was overlooked.
The appellant urged the court to set aside the awards for underpayment and overtime and reduce the house allowance award.
Respondent’s Submissions
The respondent, through their counsel, countered that:
The appellant failed to demonstrate any error warranting interference with the trial court’s judgment.
The claim of unfair termination was valid as the appellant did not provide a valid reason or follow procedural requirements.
The respondent met the burden of proof for underpayment, and the appellant failed to provide counter-evidence.
The appellant did not establish that wages included house allowance, and the limitation argument was not valid as it was not initially raised.
The respondent adequately demonstrated his working hours, justifying the overtime claim.
The respondent urged the court to dismiss the appeal with costs, arguing that the appellant failed to meet their statutory and evidential burdens.
Determination
The court has taken into consideration the Memorandum of Appeal, submissions by both parties, and the records from the trial court. The judgment will focus on evaluating whether the trial magistrate's findings were just and supported by the evidence presented. The determination will address each contested issue, including unfair termination, underpayment, overtime, and house allowance claims, to ascertain the appropriateness of the trial court's judgment.
Judgment of Appeal: Case E010 of 2026
Introduction
This document outlines the judgment delivered in the matter of an employment dispute between the Appellant and the Respondent. The case primarily revolves around the issues of unfair termination, underpayment of wages, overtime, and house allowance claims.
Termination of Employment
The Appellant initially claimed that the Respondent deserted their employment. However, in its defense, the Appellant argued that the Respondent was dismissed due to gross misconduct, asserting that due process was followed. Nevertheless, the Appellant's witnesses failed to produce any evidence, such as a notice to show cause or an invitation to a disciplinary hearing, to substantiate the claim of absenteeism.
Court's Findings
The court noted discrepancies in the evidence provided by the Appellant, particularly regarding NHIF records that predated the Respondent's employment with the Appellant. As a result, the court concluded that the Appellant did not meet the burden of proof required under sections 41, 43, and 45 of the Employment Act, thus upholding the finding that the
termination was unfair.
Underpayment of Wages
The Respondent testified to earning Kshs.8,000 per month. The Appellant failed to provide payroll records or payslips to counter this claim. According to sections 10(7) and 74 of the Employment Act, employers are obligated to maintain employment records. The court recognized the Regulation of Wages Orders as subsidiary legislation and found no reason to overturn the trial magistrate's award for underpayment.
Overtime Claims
The Respondent claimed to have worked from 5:30 p.m. to 6:00 a.m., but the record lacked sufficient detail regarding the specific days worked. The trial magistrate rejected the claim of working seven days a week as exaggerated but awarded twenty hours of overtime per week. However, the court held that the absence of employment records does not exempt an employee from proving an overtime claim. The award of Kshs.166,153.84 for overtime was deemed unsustainable and set aside.
House Allowance
Under section 31 of the Employment Act, employers must provide housing or a rent allowance unless the wage is consolidated. The Appellant did not provide any contract or payslip to show that the Respondent's salary included a house allowance. Thus, the trial magistrate's award for house allowance was upheld.
Limitation on House Allowance Claims
The Appellant argued that house allowance was recoverable only for twelve months. However, this was not raised as a ground of appeal. The court cited a precedent in G4s Security Services (K) Ltd v Ongori, noting that statutory limitations must be pleaded as a defense. The court found no basis to limit the award to Kshs.12,855.60 and upheld the award of Kshs.39,655.40.
Conclusion
The appeal succeeded only regarding the overtime claim. The court varied the judgment as follows:
The declaration of unfair termination is upheld.
Awards for underpayment of wages and house allowance are upheld.
The award of Kshs.166,153.84 for overtime is set aside.
The total monetary award is reduced from Kshs.472,032.38 to Kshs.305,878.54, with interest as ordered by the trial court.
Each party will bear its own costs of the appeal.
This judgment was delivered virtually and dated at Nairobi on the 30th of October 2026.
Presiding Judge: Abuodha Nelson Jorum

0 Comments