Significant concerns have emerged at Jomvu Girls Secondary School in Mombasa County, as the incumbent and former principals remain unable to reach consensus regarding accountability for audit discrepancies identified by the Auditor General for the fiscal year concluding on June 30, 2025.
Rebecca W. Kimondo, the current principal who assumed leadership in January 2025 succeeding Mary Kadii Bandika, contends that the audit period in question falls outside her tenure and therefore remains the responsibility of her predecessor. When contacted by Nairobi Daily News, Kimondo directed inquiries toward Bandika, asserting that the matters flagged by the Auditor General occurred during Bandika's administrative period. In her defense of her tenure, Kimondo has characterized the institution she inherited as poorly administered. She maintains that Bandika left the school's financial accounts depleted and its coffers substantially diminished. Additionally, Kimondo asserts that academic standards deteriorated under Bandika's leadership and that she is implementing enhanced academic initiatives designed to elevate the institution's performance in the 2026 KCSE examinations. Furthermore, Kimondo reports that she inherited considerable outstanding liabilities that had accumulated during Bandika's principalship.
Report of the Auditor -General on Jomvu Girls Secondary School for the Year Ended 30 June 2025 Mombasa County
Financial Statement Review
This examination of financial statements highlights several key areas of concern within the statement of financial performance, focusing on inaccuracies, unsupported expenditures, doubtful recoverability of accounts receivable, and unsupported accounts payable balances. Each issue is outlined below, providing a comprehensive overview of the financial inconsistencies observed.
1. Inaccuracies in the Statement of Financial Performance
The statement of financial performance reports total revenue of Kshs.22,841,496 and total expenditure of Kshs.17,752,436. A closer inspection reveals discrepancies in these figures:
Revenue Understatement: The reported school fund income from parents' contributions is Kshs.13,894,229, which does not align with the ledger balance of Kshs.14,138,343, resulting in an understatement of revenue by Kshs.244,114.
Expenditure Variance: The total expenditure includes Kshs.5,816,085 for operations and Kshs.10,318,201 for boarding and school fund, which differ from the ledger balances of Kshs.6,182,059 and Kshs.12,574,825, respectively. This results in unexplained variances of Kshs.365,974 and Kshs.2,256,624.
Due to these inconsistencies, the accuracy and completeness of the reported total revenue and expenditure remain unconfirmed.
2. Unsupported Expenditure on Boarding and School Fund
The financial statement indicates boarding and school fund payments totaling Kshs.10,318,201, as detailed in Note 9. However, an examination of payment vouchers, totaling Kshs.2,065,685, uncovered that these expenditures were incurred without essential supporting documents, such as:
Requisitions
Tendering records
Local purchase orders
Goods received notes
Certificates of payment
Without these documents, the occurrence, accuracy, and completeness of the boarding and school fund amount of Kshs.10,318,201 cannot be verified.
3. Doubtful Recoverability of Long Outstanding Accounts Receivable
The statement of assets and liabilities reports an accounts receivables balance of Kshs.14,045,976, as noted in Note 13. This includes Kshs.8,295,882 that has been outstanding for over two years. The absence of a policy on impairment of long-standing fee arrears raises concerns about the full recoverability of this balance. Furthermore, supporting schedules and issued invoices were not available for audit review, casting further doubt on the accuracy of the accounts receivables balance.
4. Unsupported Accounts Payable Balance
The accounts payable balance is reported as Kshs.1,098,923 in the statement of assets and liabilities, as shown in Note 14. However, essential supporting documents, including schedules, delivery notes, and invoices, were not provided for audit review. Consequently, the accuracy and completeness of the accounts payable balance of Kshs.1,098,923 remain unverified.
Overall, these findings indicate significant areas of concern regarding the financial management and reporting practices, necessitating thorough investigation and corrective measures to ensure the integrity and transparency of financial statements.
Basis for Conclusion: Irregular Transfer of Funds to KESSHA
This report highlights several key issues regarding financial management and compliance at Jontvu Girls High School for the year ended 30 June 2025, as audited by the Auditor-General. The following points summarize the main concerns:
Irregular Transfer of Funds to KESSHA
The financial statements show payments for operations and boarding, totaling Kshs.5,816,085 and Kshs.10,318,201, respectively, as mentioned in Notes 7 and 9. However, a review revealed that Kshs.1,166,420 was transferred to the Kenya Secondary School Heads Association (KESSHA), an organization comprising only school principals and not part of the government funding system. This raises questions about KESSHA's financial management capabilities and compliance with Regulation 23(2)c of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015. Consequently, the value for money transferred to KESSHA could not be confirmed.
Failure to Prepare School Improvement Plan
The school failed to develop an approved school improvement plan, contravening Section 2.2 of the Ministry of Education’s operation manual. This manual mandates schools to identify one priority area in each of the four key areas—curriculum implementation, foundational literacy and numeracy outcomes, an enabling environment for learning, and parental involvement and community engagement—every three years. The absence of this plan may hinder the school's strategic development and improvement efforts.
Overfunding of Capitation Grants
The financial statements reflect capitation grants for tuition and operations amounting to Kshs.1,568,523 and Kshs.4,698,494, respectively. However, a discrepancy was found between the student numbers reported by NEMIS (532 students) and the school’s enrolment records (433 students), resulting in an overfunding of Kshs.1,166,220. This discrepancy indicates a breach of the Ministry of Education's guidelines, suggesting either a reporting error or potential mismanagement.
Unconfirmed Student Enrolment Data
Further analysis of the student enrolment data revealed inconsistencies between the National Education Management Information System (NEMIS) and the school’s records. The NEMIS reported 532 students, while the school had only 433 on its register, leading to the overfunding mentioned previously.
This inconsistency violates the Ministry of Education Circular MOE.HQS/3/13/3 dated 25 October 2018, which requires accurate registration of all learners in NEMIS. The management's failure to ensure data accuracy constitutes a breach of the guidelines and jeopardizes the integrity of the funding process.
In summary, the report identifies significant issues in financial management and adherence to educational guidelines at Jontvu Girls High School. Addressing these concerns is crucial to ensure the lawful and effective use of public resources.
Report on the Effectiveness of Internal Controls, Risk Management, and Governance at Jomvu Girls High School
This report presents the findings from the audit conducted on Jomvu Girls High School for the year ending 30 June 2025 in Mombasa County. The audit evaluated the effectiveness of internal controls, risk management, and governance practices in place at the school. Below are the key findings:
1. Non-disclosure of Assets and Weaknesses in Asset Management
The financial statements, as detailed in Annex 2, indicated that the school possessed fixed assets worth Kshs.208,178,112. However, the fixed asset register failed to include land assets. Although the management acknowledged possession of land, the title deed was not provided to confirm its size and ownership. The land was reportedly donated by the Methodist Church in Kenya, Changamwe Circuit.
In the absence of this documentation, the effectiveness of internal controls and risk management concerning these assets could not be confirmed.
2. Inadequate Safeguards in Revenue Collection
The statement of financial performance disclosed in Note 4 showed school fund income from parents' contributions totaling Kshs.13,894,229. However, the audit revealed a lack of segregation of duties in revenue collection. The same officer was responsible for billing, collecting, recording, and reconciling the school fund income, which contravenes Regulation 63 (1, a) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations 2015. This regulation mandates that accounting officers and revenue receivers ensure adequate safeguards and proper accounting for revenue.
Due to this, the internal controls on revenue collection and necessary safeguards were found to be weak.
3. Underutilization of Financial Management System
The review showed that the school had implemented the Somsom Financial Management System. Nevertheless, it was only used for managing students' fee balances, while other crucial financial management functions such as expenditure management, reporting, and financial statement generation were done manually. This was due to the non-activation of the relevant modules within the system.
As a result, the benefits associated with automated financial management systems could not be realized.
4. Failure to Hold Board of Management Meetings
The Board of Management records indicated only two meetings were held during the year, contrary to section 6 (1) of the 4th Schedule of the Basic Education Act, which requires meetings at least once every four months. Furthermore, the minutes were unsigned by both the secretary and the Chairman, and there was no board register to confirm board members' attendance.
Therefore, the effectiveness of the governance mechanism at the school could not be verified.
5. Effectiveness in Textbook Management
The school received 4,302 textbooks from the Kenya Institute of Curriculum Development during the review period. However, there were no systems in place to manage textbooks from previous periods. Additionally, there were no documented policies on the issuance, control, recovery, and management of textbooks, making it difficult to efficiently monitor textbook stock levels and student-to-textbook ratios.
Consequently, the effectiveness of internal controls on textbook management could not be confirmed.


0 Comments