The Principal of Ngatotoek Mixed Boarding Secondary School, Peter M. Gathaga, may soon be summoned before the parliamentary committee on Public Investment and Education to address audit inquiries raised by the Auditor General in the school's financial report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, which has revealed significant institutional deterioration, corrupt practices, and financial mismanagement. Stakeholders are now expressing serious concerns that since assuming the position of principal in August 2023, Gathaga has failed to advance the school's infrastructure development or academic performance. No substantial projects have been successfully initiated or completed under his leadership. The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) is facing mounting pressure from parents, stakeholders, members of the Board of Management (BoG), and representatives of the Parents Association (PA) to transfer Gathaga by the conclusion of the current term. Failure to comply with this demand has prompted threats of physical removal from the school premises in January 2027. A replacement candidate has already been identified—a principal from Kajiado County with local community ties. Gathaga stands accused of authoritarian conduct, intimidation, coercion, and threatening behavior. Members of the Parents Association (PA) refuse to endorse unauthorized financial practices, including illegal levies that primarily benefit Gathaga personally. The school has accumulated substantial outstanding debts because payments are made selectively only to those willing to provide him with financial kickbacks. Institutional discipline has deteriorated significantly, with documented allegations of sexual misconduct and harassment. Gathaga reportedly fails to take appropriate action when such incidents are reported. Students allege his inaction stems from his involvement in an undisclosed extramarital relationship with a Form Four student, a relationship that commenced the previous year. His conduct demonstrates serious moral deficiency and professional unsuitability for his position.
To enhance the institution's academic performance on the Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education examination, during the previous academic year, the administrator solicited monetary contributions from parents under the pretext of with the stated purpose of facilitating examination irregularities. Specifically, these funds were intended to compromise the integrity of examination invigilators and officials, thereby enabling candidates to engage in academic dishonesty and violate examination protocols.
Consequently, the school achieved a mean score of 6 through these illicit practices, as students were permitted to cheat. In the current academic year, credible reports suggest that the administrator has again requested parental contributions. Given the present circumstances, the school has come under scrutiny by the Kenya National Examination Council, and should any irregularities be identified, the examination results will be invalidated. Parents of the candidates have declared that the administrator must assume complete accountability should the 2026 Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education results be annulled due to examination irregularities.Report of the Auditor-General on Ngatotoek Mixed Boarding Secondary School for the Year Ended 30 June, 2025 - Kajiado County
Unsupported Personnel Emoluments
The financial statements reveal a total boarding school fund expenditure of Kshs.7,760,140, which includes personnel emoluments amounting to Kshs.1,268,285. However, crucial documents such as the scheme of service for non-teaching staff and Board of Management (BOM) teachers, as well as a staff establishment, were not available for the audit review.
Additionally, the Board of Management minutes, which would confirm the approval of staff appointments, were missing. Consequently, the accuracy and completeness of the personnel emolument balance of Kshs.7,760,140 remain unverified.
Unsupported Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables
According to Note 13 in the financial statements, the balance for accounts receivables stands at Kshs.2,427,497, primarily due to fees arrears. Within this balance, Kshs.597,192 represents receivables outstanding for over a year. Unfortunately, the audit review was hindered by the absence of supporting schedules for these long-standing receivables.
Moreover, no policy regarding the impairment of these arrears was provided, casting doubt on the full recoverability of the accounts receivables balance. This lack of documentation challenges the confirmation of the accuracy and completeness of the Kshs.2,427,497 accounts receivables balance.
Unsupported Long Outstanding Accounts Payables
The financial statements, as highlighted in Note 14, indicate an accounts payables balance of Kshs.7,606,357, which has been outstanding for over three years. The audit could not verify this balance due to inadequate supporting records, such as invoices, local purchase orders, and contracts. As a result, the accuracy and completeness of the Kshs.7,606,357 accounts payables balance remain questionable.
Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern
The Statement of Receipts and Payments shows a deficit of Kshs.1,093,519. Furthermore, the Statement of Assets and Liabilities reveals current assets and liabilities of Kshs.3,004,875 and Kshs.7,606,357, respectively. This results in a negative working capital of Kshs.7,606,357. Despite this significant material uncertainty, it was not disclosed as a note in the financial statements, raising concerns about the school's ability to continue as a going concern.
This report highlights critical areas where documentation and financial management need improvement to ensure transparency and accountability at Ngatotoek Mked Boarding Secondary School.
Failure to Transfer Infrastructure Funds from Operations Bank Account
The financial statements for the year under review reveal operations capitation grants amounting to Kshs. 1,947,877, which include Kshs. 564,750 designated for infrastructure grants. However, only Kshs. 453,000 was transferred from the operations account to the infrastructure account, resulting in an unexplained variance of Kshs. 111,750.
Additionally, the transfer of Kshs. 453,000 did not occur within the 15-day period as mandated by the Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No: MOE.HQS/311313-2021. This directive requires that infrastructure and maintenance improvement funds be moved to the school infrastructure account within fifteen days of receipt in the operations account.
The failure to adhere to these guidelines denies the school vital funds for infrastructure improvement.
Consequently, the Management's actions constituted a breach of the Ministry of Education Circular.
Irregular Transfer of Funds to Kenya Secondary Schools Heads Association
The financial statements also disclose a boarding and school fund expenditure of Kshs. 7,760,140, which includes Kshs. 28,000 transferred to the Kenya Secondary School Heads Association (KESSHA). KESSHA is a welfare organization for school principals, not recognized within the Government funding system.
There is no assurance that KESSHA has effective financial management and internal control systems, as required by Regulation 23(2)(c) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015. This regulation mandates an Accounting Officer to secure a written assurance from any entity receiving funds that it implements efficient, transparent financial management and internal controls.
As a result, the Management's actions were in breach of the law, and the value for money transferred could not be ascertained.
Failure to Prepare School Improvement Plan
During the reviewed year, Ngatataek Mixed Boarding Secondary School operated without an Approved School Improvement Plan. This is contrary to Section 2.2 of the Ministry of Education Operation Manual for Utilization of Learner Capitation Grant and Other School Funds. The manual requires schools to identify one priority area within each of four key areas—curriculum implementation, foundational literacy and numeracy outcomes, enabling learning environments, and parental and community engagement—every three years for school improvement planning.
In this regard, the Management was in breach of the Ministry of Education Operation Manual.
Non-Compliance with Law on Affirmative Action
Records indicate that the school has 14 Board of Management staff (both teaching and non-teaching), with one ethnic group representing 50% of the employees. This exceeds the legal threshold of 33%, as stipulated by Article 27(8) of the Constitution, which requires no more than two-thirds of members in any public body to be of the same gender or ethnic group. Furthermore, the school employs no staff with disabilities, contrary to the Persons with Disabilities Act, 2003, which mandates at least 5% representation.
Therefore, Management was in breach of the law.
This report reviews and highlights key issues identified during the audit of Ngatataek Mixed Boarding Secondary School for the year ended 30 June 2025. The audit, conducted by the Auditor-General, revealed significant discrepancies and shortcomings in various operational aspects of the school.
Discrepancies in Enrollment Data
The audit noted a discrepancy between the student enrollment data recorded in the National Education Management Information System (NEMIS) and the school's own records. NEMIS reported a total of 149 students, whereas the school's records indicated 178 students, resulting in a variance of 24 students. This discrepancy could lead to underfunding or overfunding, which may negatively impact school activities and service delivery.
Implications of Enrollment Discrepancies
Financial Impact: Misaligned student numbers can lead to incorrect allocation of government funding.
Operational Challenges: Inconsistent data may disrupt planning and resource management.
Service Delivery: The quality and scope of educational services offered to students might be adversely affected.
Lack of Procurement Function
The audit identified that the school lacked a functional procurement unit managed by a qualified procurement professional. This deficiency undermines the effectiveness of the procurement process, which is crucial for acquiring goods and services efficiently and economically.
Consequences of Ineffective Procurement
Increased Costs: Without a structured procurement process, the school may incur unnecessary expenses.
Delayed Acquisitions: Inefficiencies can lead to delays in obtaining essential educational materials and resources.
Non-compliance: The absence of a procurement function may result in non-compliance with regulatory requirements.
Failure to Maintain Fixed Assets Register
The audit found that the financial statements included a summary of the fixed assets register with a disclosed nil historical cost, but no supporting register was provided for review. This lack of documentation raises questions about the management and accountability of the school’s assets.
Risks Associated with Poor Asset Management
Asset Mismanagement: Without a proper register, tracking and managing assets become challenging.
Financial Inaccuracy: The absence of detailed asset documentation can lead to inaccurate financial reporting.
Operational Inefficiency: Unaccounted assets can hinder the school's ability to make informed decisions regarding maintenance and investment.
Conclusion
The audit highlights critical areas needing improvement at Ngatataek Mixed Boarding Secondary School. Addressing these discrepancies and deficiencies is essential to ensure effective internal controls, risk management, and governance. Implementing corrective measures will enhance the school's operational efficiency and service delivery, ultimately benefiting the students and the broader community.

0 Comments