Principal James Kiiru of Kirangari Boys High School finds himself in a precarious situation as stakeholders, including parents, teachers, members of the Board of Management (BoM), and the Parents Association (PA), have collectively called for his transfer by the conclusion of the third term.Sources indicate that this demand for his transfer arises from revelations in the auditor general's report concerning Kirangari Boys for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025. It is noteworthy that Kiiru assumed leadership in July 2024, and the audit report pertains to the period of 2025, marking one year since he took office. The report has uncovered significant issues, including mismanagement, corruption, and various forms of misconduct attributed to the principal.
REPORT OF THE AUDITOR.GENERAL ON KIRANGAR! BOYS HIGH SCHOOL FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE, 2025- KIAMBU COUNTY
Audit Report Summary: Kirangari Boys High School
This report provides a summary of the audit findings for Kirangari Boys High School for the year ended 30 June, 2025. The audit identified several areas of concern, including unsupported accounts payables, long outstanding accounts receivables, late transfer of infrastructure funds, project implementation delays, and irregularities in the procurement process.
Unsupported Accounts Payables
The statement of assets and liabilities reflects an accounts payables balance of Kshs. 25,706,760 as disclosed under Note 14 of the financial statements. However, management did not provide a detailed ageing analysis or supporting schedules. Additionally, Annex 1 of the financial statements, which analyzes pending accounts payables, shows an outstanding balance of Kshs. 13,599,723, resulting in an unexplained variance of Kshs. 12,107,037. Consequently, the accuracy and completeness of the accounts payables balance could not be confirmed.
Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables
The accounts receivables balance is recorded as Kshs. 30,589,365 in respect to fees arrears, as disclosed in Note 13. Notably, Kshs. 25,166,840, which accounts for 82%, has been outstanding for over three years. The absence of supporting schedules and a policy on the impairment of long outstanding fees raises doubts about the recoverability of these receivables. Therefore, the accuracy and completeness of the accounts receivables balance could not be confirmed.
Late Transfer of Infrastructure Funds
The financial performance statement reflects government grants for operations amounting to Kshs. 9,041,046 as disclosed in Note 2. Included is Kshs. 3,487,000 intended for infrastructure grants, which was not transferred to the infrastructure bank account within the required 15-day period. This delay contravenes the Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No. MOE.HQS/311313,2021, thus breaching regulations.
Project Implementation Status
Delayed Construction of Laboratory Extension
The school commenced a laboratory vertical extension project at a contract sum of Kshs. 24,771,450 under tender No. KBHS/TruIEXTlLABl0112024. The contract, signed on 17 April 2024, required completion by 26 November 2024, yet it remained incomplete as of March 2026. No requests or approvals for contract extension were documented, and the absence of progress reports hindered audit verification. The delay deprived the public of the project's benefits.
Irregularities in Procurement Process
Lack of Segregation of Duties
The procurement process for various items, including vegetables, fresh beef, electrical supplies, and maintenance services, lacked proper segregation of duties. Audit review revealed the same ad-hoc committee members were responsible for both opening and evaluating bids, violating Section 78(1)(b) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. This section mandates that an accounting officer appoints a tender opening committee with at least one member not involved in processing or evaluating tenders.
These findings highlight critical areas for improvement in financial management and operational compliance at Kirangari Boys High School. Addressing these issues is essential for enhancing transparency, accountability, and effective resource utilization.
Analysis of Procurement and Management Issues at Kirangari Boys High School for the Year Ended 30 June, 2025
This report presents an overview of several critical issues identified during the audit of Kirangari Boys High School's procurement process and management practices for the financial year ending 30 June, 2025. The findings highlight non-compliance with various legal and regulatory requirements, as detailed below.
1. Failure of the Tender Opening Committee to Sign Minutes
A review of the procurement process revealed that for most procurements, the tender opening committee minutes were not signed by all members. This contravenes Section 78(11) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015, which mandates that each member of the tender opening committee must initial each page of the minutes and append their signature, including their full name and designation on the final page. The absence of these signatures indicates that the minutes may not be a true reflection of the tender opening proceedings.
2. Lack of Evaluation Committee Initials on Evaluation Report
The audit also uncovered that the tender evaluation reports lacked the necessary initials from committee members, as required by Section 83(3) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. This section requires each member to initial every page of the report to confirm its accuracy. Additionally, the final evaluation reports were not signed by all members, signifying non-compliance with the law.
3. Failure to Issue a Professional Opinion
The procurement review revealed that no professional opinions were issued by the head of procurement, contrary to Section 84(1) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015. This section requires the head of procurement to review the tender evaluation report and provide a signed professional opinion to the accounting officer. The absence of this professional opinion indicates a breach of the law by management.
4. Non-Compliance with Staffing of Persons with Disabilities
The audit of the Board of Management staff revealed a lack of compliance with Section 8.23 (1) of the Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manual for the Public Service, May 2016. The school employed thirty staff members, none of whom identified as persons with disabilities. This is contrary to the requirement that at least five percent of all appointments be reserved for persons with disabilities, thus violating the law.
5. Irregular Transfer of Funds to Kenya Secondary Schools Heads Association
The financial statements for the year reflected an unexplained transfer of Kshs.2,351,000 to the Kenya Secondary Schools Heads Association (KESSHA) from the boarding and school fund. KESSHA, a welfare organization for school principals, is not defined within the Government Funding system, raising concerns about the effective management and transparency of these funds. Consequently, the value for money of this transfer could not be confirmed.
6. Non-Deduction of Capacity Building Levy
Lastly, the audit identified non-compliance with the Levy Order, 2023 issued by the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority. The school failed to deduct the public procurement capacity building levy of 0.03% on procurement contracts, reflecting a breach of legal requirements.
These findings underline the need for Kirangari Boys High School to enhance its compliance with statutory requirements and improve its internal controls and governance practices to ensure transparency, accountability, and value for money in its operations.
Audit Findings on Financial and Operational Irregularities
Irregular Payment of Allowances to Teachers
The financial statement reflects boarding and school fund amounts totaling Kshs.55,679,252, as disclosed in Note 9. Upon reviewing payment vouchers and supporting documents, it was found that extra allowances amounting to Kshs.4,283,000 were paid to teachers for Performance Improvement Programme (PIP) activities.
These payments lacked approval from the Cabinet Secretary of Education and the Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC). Additionally, there were no approved guidelines supporting the basis of computation, eligible participants, attendance schedules, or necessary authorizations. This oversight indicates that management breached legal requirements.
Unapproved Budget
The statement of budgeted versus actual amounts reveals a budgeted income of Kshs.92,341,240 compared to an actual income of Kshs.74,309,627. It was noted that revenue of Kshs.645,750 was not included in the approved budget. Furthermore, the statement reflects budgeted and actual expenditures of Kshs.91,688,820 and Kshs.87,532,997, respectively.
Expenditure of Kshs.359,090 was also omitted from the approved budget without evidence of budget reallocation or supplementary approval. This violates Regulation 31(2Xa) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015, resulting in a breach of the law by management.
Irregular Use of Cash for Procurement
The financial statement shows a total expenditure of Kshs.88,624,598. However, analysis revealed cash payments amounting to Kshs.28,120,424 were used for goods, works, and services. This contravenes Section 103(2) of the Public Procurement and Assets Disposal Act, 2015, which specifies circumstances for direct procurement. Consequently, management breached the legal requirements.
Underfunding of Capitation Grants
Capitation grants for tuition and operations were reported as Kshs.2,845,024 and Kshs.9,041,046, respectively. Discrepancies arose between the National Education Management Information System (NEMIS) report, indicating an average of 1,007 students, and the school's enrolment records, which showed 1,224 students. This variance of 217 students led to underfunding of Kshs.3,491,220, potentially affecting public service delivery.
Late Submission of Financial Statements
Financial statements for the reviewed year were submitted on 02 October, 2025, instead of the mandated date of 31 August, 2025, as directed by The National Treasury Circular No. AG.3/88 Vol.Vll (41) dated 4 December, 2024. This delay constitutes a breach of legal requirements by management.
Failure to Prepare School Improvement Plan
The school did not have an approved School Improvement Plan during the reviewed year, violating Section 2.2 of the Ministry of Education Operation Manual. This section mandates schools to identify one priority area in four key areas every three years. The absence of this plan indicates non-compliance with legal obligations by management.
Report on Effectiveness of Internal Controls, Risk Management, and Governance
1. Unapproved Board of Management Allowances
The financial performance statement indicates an expenditure of Kshs.88,624,598, which includes Kshs.55,679,252 for boarding and school fund expenses. The School expended Kshs.636,000 for board member allowances at a rate of Kshs.3,000 per meeting. The absence of approval from the Cabinet Secretary, Education, and advice from the Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC) raises concerns about the governance mechanisms' effectiveness at the School.
2. Failure to Provide Committee Minutes
During the reviewed financial year, the School failed to maintain notices for committee meetings, attendance registers, and minutes, violating Section 9 of the Sixth Schedule of the Basic Education Act, 2013. This lapse indicates non-compliance and raises concerns about the management's adherence to legal requirements.
3. Weaknesses in Management of Assets
Annex 2 of the financial statements summarizes a fixed assets register that includes approximately thirty-nine acres of land. However, the School Management did not provide evidence of ownership, as the land is registered under the Church Commissioners for Kenya. This lack of documentation raises questions about the effectiveness of the School's asset management.
4. Lack of Internal Audit Reviews
The School did not comply with Regulation 166(1) and (2) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015, which mandates internal performance appraisal and annual review of the internal audit activity. This oversight failure compromises the School's effective oversight mechanisms.
5. Weaknesses in Human Resource Management
The School employed twenty-one non-teaching staff, yet personnel records lacked valid appointment letters or clear service contracts. Management had not developed a Human Resource Policy or Plan to guide recruitment, deployment, and contract processes.
Additionally, some staff were reassigned without documented appraisals or competency assessments, undermining effective human resource management controls.
Overall, the issues highlighted raise significant concerns about the effectiveness of internal controls, risk management, and governance at Kirangari Boys High School, necessitating urgent attention to improve compliance and operational efficiency.

0 Comments