Hirjibhai Ragwani of Shree Swaminarayan Temple Vadtaldham Charitable Trust unfairly sacked committee member



The Shree Swaminarayan Temple Vadtaldham Charitable Trust has experienced a significant legal setback following a ruling by Nairobi High Court Judge W. Musyoka on 22nd October 2026. In Judicial Review No. E195 Of 2026, the court rendered judgment in favour of Pritesh Devji Kanji Mavji Kerai, who had initiated legal proceedings against the Trust.

The individual subject to these allegations is Mr. Hirjibhai Ragwani, who serves as a distinguished community leader and principal trustee or representative affiliated with the trust and its regional branch administration, particularly the well-regarded.

Pursuant to the judgment, the court issued an order nullifying the decision to remove the petitioner from the Kitchen Committee. Rather than mandating reinstatement, the court directed the respondent to provide monetary compensation to the petitioner in the amount of Kshs. 500,000. Pritesh Devji Kanji Mavji Kerai successfully pursued and won his legal action. The Trust has been characterized by authoritarian governance practices, coercion, threats, and intimidation, with individuals who raise concerns facing dismissal. The Trust has encountered financial irregularities and general mismanagement of its resources. There are substantive calls for conducting fresh elections to replace the current office bearers, who face allegations of lacking transparency and accountability. 

Additionally, allegations of sexual misconduct have emerged, wherein a senior trustee is reported to be engaged in an extramarital relationship with a trustee member. The two individuals have been observed together at upscale establishments dining and subsequently retiring to hotel accommodations.
  


.Judicial Review Remedies: Case Analysis

Background

The petitioner, a former member of the Kitchen Committee of the respondent, was removed from his position. The respondent justified this removal by citing the petitioner’s alleged unacceptable behavior. However, the core issue in this matter is not the justification for the removal but rather the due process—or lack thereof—that was followed.


Due Process and Judicial Review

Judicial review focuses on the adherence to due process rather than the merits of the decision itself. Before removing an individual from a position, certain procedural steps must be taken. This includes notifying the individual of the intended action, detailing the allegations against them, and giving them an opportunity to be heard. The petitioner alleges that these steps were not followed in his case, as he was not given the chance to account for his actions prior to the decision being made.


Failure to Observe Constitutional Rules

In this specific case, the respondent failed to comply with Rules 19 to 21 of its constitution. These rules require that a notice be served, reasons for dismissal be provided and explained, and an opportunity for a hearing be offered before dismissal. No evidence was presented to show that the petitioner was subjected to the disciplinary proceedings outlined in these rules.


Applicability of the Fair Administrative Action Act

The Fair Administrative Action Act applies to non-State entities like the respondent. This Act ensures that judicial review remedies are available against such bodies. It was enacted to give effect to Article 47 of the Constitution and broadens the scope of judicial review beyond what is initially contemplated in the Article.


The Exhaustion Doctrine

Before resorting to the court, internal mechanisms, such as an appeal under Rule 23 of the respondent’s constitution, should be exhausted. However, this appeal process could only be initiated after the respondent complied with Rules 19 to 21, which did not happen in this case. Attempts at mediation failed, leaving court action as the only viable option.


Conclusion and Determination

The court concluded that the petitioner established a case of unfair administrative action. The decision to remove the petitioner lacked adherence to the principles of natural justice. The petitioner sought reinstatement, but the court determined that compensation was a more suitable remedy. Reinstatement could force an undesirable relationship between the parties.


Disposition

The court allowed the petition, and the following orders were made:

  • A declaration that the petitioner’s dismissal was unlawful, procedurally unfair, and violated natural justice principles.

  • The decision to dismiss the petitioner was quashed.

  • Rather than reinstatement, the respondent is directed to compensate the petitioner with Kshs. 500,000.00.

  • The petitioner is awarded the costs of the petition.


Court Details
  • Delivered: Via CTS, dated and signed in chambers, at Milimani, Nairobi, on 22nd October 2026.

  • Judge: W Musyoka

  • Court Assistant: Mr. Abdirahman

  • Legal Researcher: Ms. L Wafula

Advocates
  • For the Petitioner: Mr. Mukathe, Messrs. Maina Makome & Company, Advocates.

  • For the Respondent: Mr. Macharia, Messrs. Macharia Gaitho & Murigu Advocates LLP.


Case Background and Allegations

Introduction

The petitioner, a lawful member of the respondent organization and its Kitchen Committee, filed a petition dated 4th June 2026. The affidavits sworn on 4th June 2026 and 19th August 2026 accompany this petition, outlining the background of the case.


Membership and Dismissal

The petitioner claims that on or around 22nd March 2025, he was removed from the Kitchen Committee without notice. Despite his efforts to seek clarification from the respondent regarding the reasons for his dismissal, his inquiries were unsuccessful.

Grounds for Application

The petitioner asserts that his dismissal lacked prior notice and a hearing, and no reasons were provided for the decision.


Supporting Documents

The petitioner has attached several documents to support his case:

  • A copy of the trustee deed dated 9th July 2018, governing the respondent.

  • An undated, unsigned document addressed to him, communicating his removal from the committee.

  • A letter dated 27th March 2025, protesting meetings held without him.

  • Additional letters dated 28th March 2025 and 10th April 2025, protesting his suspension.

  • A letter from his advocates, dated 11th April 2025.


Responses to the Application

Respondent's Opposition

The respondent opposes the petition through affidavits sworn by Mr. Hirjibhai Ragwani on 30th June 2026 and 24th July 2026. The respondent refers to Rule 29 of its Constitution, which mandates unresolved disputes to be addressed by the Managing Trustee Board.


Reasons for Dismissal

The respondent contends that the petitioner's conduct was hostile, compromising the temple's required safe and spiritually pure environment. This situation necessitated immediate management intervention. An emergency meeting held on 26th March 2025 led to the decision to remove the petitioner due to his behavior with the women at the kitchen and his intemperate language towards the secretary.


Submissions

Petitioner’s Submissions

The petitioner, in submissions dated 19th August 2026, argues that his removal adversely affected his position and legitimate expectations, invoking section 2 of the Fair Administrative Action Act. He emphasizes his right to defend himself and points out that the decision-making process lacked procedural fairness, as he was merely notified of the outcome via WhatsApp. 


The petitioner asserts that several mediation meetings failed to resolve the dispute and cites various constitutional articles and legal precedents to support his case.


Respondent’s Submissions

The respondent's written submissions, dated 14th September 2026, focus on four main issues:

  1. Whether a case for judicial review orders has been established.

  2. Whether the court should intervene in the internal governance of a private religious institution.

  3. Whether the impugned decision constitutes an administrative action subject to judicial review.

  4. Whether the petition is premature due to the failure to exhaust internal resolution mechanisms.


The respondent references constitutional provisions and legal precedents to argue against the petitioner's claims.


Conclusion

The case presents a complex legal scenario involving procedural fairness, internal dispute resolution mechanisms, and the balance between private religious governance and legal oversight. Both parties have presented detailed submissions supported by legal precedents and statutory provisions, awaiting judicial determination.

Post a Comment

0 Comments