KIRINGARI BOYS HIGH UNDER FIRE: FINANCIAL IRREGULARITIES AND GOVERNANCE FAILURES-AUDIT REVELATIONS SHAKE THE SCHOOL TO ITS CORE


The principal of Kiringari Boys High School, Mr. James Kiiru, finds himself in a precarious situation following revelations from the Auditor General regarding instances of mismanagement, loss of public funds, and procurement irregularities.
Stakeholders, including parents, members of the Parents Association, and the Board of Management, have collectively concluded that it is time for him to be transferred. 

They argue that he has not only failed to meet the standards set by his predecessor but has also not succeeded in enhancing the school’s academic performance and infrastructure development. The school has not recorded a mean score exceeding 5.5 since 2020. Concerns have been raised that he governs the school with an iron fist, employing coercion, intimidation, and threats against those who express differing opinions. He allegedly coerces members of the Parents Association into endorsing unlawful practices, such as unauthorized levies, and those who challenge these actions face severe repercussions and victimization. The school is reportedly in significant debt to suppliers, with payments being made only to those who agree to provide bribes and kickbacks, despite the board's approval of payments. There are allegations of collusion between him and the bursar/finance officer, Simon Mwangi, to falsify school fee records, suggesting that students owe the school millions of shillings. However, parents assert that no such debts exist, as the principal has consistently maintained a policy of zero balance. In light of these issues, parents, stakeholders, and the board are now urging the Teachers Service Commission to transfer him by the beginning of the first term in 2027 and to appoint a local teacher to manage the school. They have warned that failure to do so may result in physical eviction from the school premises in January of next year.

REPORT OF THE AUDITOR.GENERAL ON KIRANGARI BOYS HIGH SCHOOL FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE, 2025- KIAMBU COUNTY 

Long Outstanding Accounts Receivables

The statement of assets and liabilities reflects accounts receivables balance of Kshs.30,589,365 in respect of fees arrears as disclosed in Note 13 to the financial statements.

lncluded in the balance is accounts receivables balance of Kshs.25,166,840 or 82o/o which had been outstanding for more than three (3) years.

ln addition, there were no supporting schedules and policy on the impairment of long outstanding fees arrears casting doubt on full recoverability of the accounts receivables balance.

ln the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the accounts receivables balance of Kshs.30,589,365 could not be confirmed.

lrregular Payment of Allowances to Teachers for Performance lmprovement Programme

The statement of financial performance reflects boarding and school fund amount of Kshs.55,679 ,252 as disclosed in Note 9 to the financial statements.

Review of payment vouchers and supporting documents under the school fund account revealed that Management paid teachers' extra allowances for Performance lmprovement Programme (PlP) activities amounting to Kshs.4,283,000 during the year under review.

However, the allowances were not supported by approval from the Cabinet Secretary of Education and advisory from the Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC).

Further, the payments were not supported by approved guidelines indicating the basis of computation, eligible participants, attendance schedules, or authorization from the relevant oversight authorities.

ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

lrregular Use of Gash to Procure Goods, Works and Services

The statements of financial performance reflects a total expenditure of Kshs.88,624,598. However, analysis of cash books for operations and boarding and school fund account revealed that the School used a total of Kshs.28,120,424 in cash payments for goods, work and services.

This was contrary to the provisions of Section 103(2) of the Public Procurement and Assets DisposalAct, 2015 which lays down the circumstances under which direct procurement may be applied.

ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

 

Unapproved Board of Management Allowances

The statement of financial performance reflects an expenditure of Kshs.88,624,598. lncluded in this amount under Note 9 to the financial statements is boarding and school fund expenditure amounting to Kshs.55,679,252 where board expenses were incurred.

lt was noted that the School incurred board expenses amounting to Kshs.636,000 during the year under review.

A rate of Kshs.3,000 was used to renumerate the board members for sitting and travelling allowance during the full board meetings, executive meetings and committee meetings.

lt was not clear how the school arrived at the rate of Kshs.3,000 since there is no approval from the Cabinet Secretary, Education with an advice from the Salaries and Renumeration Commission (SRC).

ln the circumstances, the effectiveness of the governance mechanism at the School could not be confirmed

 

Late Transfer of lnfrastructure Funds from the Operations Bank Account

The statement of financial performance for the year ended 30 June, 2025 reflects government grants for operations amount of Kshs.9,041,046 as disclosed in Note 2 to the financial statements from the Ministry of Education credited into the operations bank account.

lncluded in the amount is Kshs.3,487,000 in respect of infrastructure grants which were to be transferred to infrastructure bank account for maintenance and improvement of the School's facilities.

However, it was not transferred from operations account to the infrastructure account within fifteen (15) days requirement period. This was contrary to the Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No. MOE.HQS/311313,2021 which directed that infrastructure grants as well as maintenance and improvement funds should be transferred to the School infrastructure account fifteen (15) days upon receipt of the funds in the operations account.

ln the circumstances, Management is in breach of the law.

Delayed construction of a Vertical Extension of the school's Laboratory

During the year under review, the School undertook a Laboratory vertical extension project under tender No. KBHS/TruIEXTlLABl0112024 at a contract sum of Kshs.24,771,450.

Review of the contract agreement signed of 17 April, 2024 required the project to be competed on 26 November,2024.

However, the project was not complete at the time of audit in March, 2026. No request and approvals for extension of the contract was undertaken.

ln addition, the Performance bond was issued by Cannon General insurance on 22 April 2024, for (5) days after signing of the contract and there were no progress reports provided for audit verifications.

ln the circumstances, the delayed completion of the project denied the public the benefits derived from the completed project.

lrregularities in Procurement Process

Lack of Segregation of Duties

The School Managements invited for bids for supply, delivery of goods, services and works for the period starting 01 July, 2024 to 30 June, 2025 for various ltems among which includes vegetables and green groceries, fresh beef/steak, electrical supplies, plumbing services, CCTV accessories and maintenance among others.

However, audit review of the procurement processes revealed the same adhoc committee members opened and evaluated the bids on 24 June, 2024 contrary to Section 78(1)(b) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 which requires an accounting officer of a procuring entity to appoint a tender opening committee specifically for the procurement and that at least one (1) of the members shall not be directly involved in the processing or evaluation of the tenders.

Failure of the tender opening committee to sign the tender opening minutes A review of the procurement process revealed that for most of the procurements, opening committee minutes were not signed by all members contrary to Section 78(11) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 which states that each member of the tender opening committee shall initial each page of the minutes and append his or her signature as well as initial to the final page of the minutes indicating their full name and designation.

This will be an indication that the minutes are a true reflection of the tender opening committee.

Lack of Evaluation Committee

Initials on Evaluation Report Section 83(3) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 requires each member of the tender evaluation committee to initial every page of the report to confirm that they are a true reflection of the proceedings.

However, review of the tender evaluation reports revealed that the commiftee members did not initial the evaluation reports as mandated by the Act, indicating non-compliance with the law.

lt was also noted that the final evaluation reports were not signed by all the members.

Non-Deduction of Capacity Building Levy

The statement of financial performance reflects payments for boarding and school fund amount of Kshs.55,679,252 and as disclosed in Note 9 to the financial statements. The payments include procurement contracts signed with the School's suppliers.

Review of payments for goods and services revealed that there was no deduction of the public procurement capacity building levy of 0.03% on the contracts, contrary to the Levy Order, 2023 issued by the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority.

ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law

 

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments